Taking a break from my normal mom of a large family rambling posts to address an issue that just won't die. Somehow Senator Debbie Stabenow got Jesse's work email address. I bet when this bulk email went out to him she wasn't expecting his reply. Senator Stabenow gives the basic arguments without the facts including assuming that men don't know anything about women's reproductive "health". Well...look for yourself. Jesse's response follows. She may never read it and if she does she may laugh it off but his family read it and we are grateful for his willingness to stand up for truth, for our Faith, and for families.
Dear Jesse,
I wanted to take a minute to tell you about what we're working on in the Senate to respond to the Supreme Court's terrible decision to allow employers to make health decisions for women.
The Court's recent decision allows companies to pick and choose what women's health care services they will cover. At a time when so many women and families are struggling to make ends meet, it is unbelievable that five men on the Supreme Court would decide to shift additional costs onto women.
Later today the Senate is scheduled to vote on a bill I cosponsored that would prohibit employers from refusing to provide women health services that are required by law. Employers shouldn't be able to dictate the very personal decision of what's best for a woman and her family.
Can you imagine having to ask your boss to weigh in on such a personal decision about your reproductive health?
We fought hard to make sure that being a woman couldn't be counted as a "pre-existing condition" and to stop insurance companies from charging women more for health care just because they are women. I led the fight to make sure insurance companies covered comprehensive preventive care for women – including birth control, cancer screenings, and maternity care. Women in this country, many of whom are breadwinners for their families, should not be asked to pay more for their health care.
You can count on me to support the legislation in the Senate and to continue fighting for Michigan families. Please make your voice heard! Only by working together can we effectively strengthen and improve the lives of women and families in our country.
Debbie Stabenow
United States Senator
********************************************************************************
Dear Senator Stabenow –
I wanted to let you know that I am one of your constituents that is very much in favor of the Supreme Court’s excellent decision to allow employers to make decisions in accordance with their respective religious beliefs.
The court’s recent decision makes it so that a company does not have to choose between violating their closely held and important religious beliefs and paying a fine to an overreaching government. If you were more familiar with the decision that those 5 men on the Supreme Court had made and were capable of doing a cursory Google search on the actual specifics of the decision, you would find that the decision still allows women to purchase a wide variety of birth control through their company provided insurance. It only limits those forms of birth control that actually kill the baby in the women’s womb after it has been conceived. I must say that I am very disappointed that you, as a representative to millions of Michigan residents would be so ill informed regarding this decision, and as the media at large did, resort to such grandiose fear mongering that is so blatantly false. Your ill-informed propaganda caters to the lowest common denominator sound bite audience that take your erroneous statements as gospel and spew your falsities back on anyone who will listen.
Unfortunately, I feel compelled to turn your sound bite techniques back on you and throw the almost cliché quote “If you repeat a lie enough times, it will become the truth” back at you. While I understand that this logic is one of the most commonly used tools in you and many of your colleagues’ arsenals, that, unfortunately for you and your ilk, does not make it any more valid than it was when it was originally stated in Nazi propaganda.
One of the key underlying issues that I have never understood in this whole debate is when did free birth control become a “right”. When did it become the job of the government to subsidize a women’s desire to prevent pregnancy? And for that matter, when did pregnancy become this horrid disease that you and collaborators feel the need to prevent at all costs? Pregnancy is a gift from God, and is the natural result of a natural act. This is a fact that those who would believe the lies that you spread seem to consistently overlook and conveniently ignore. Pregnancy is not something that needs to be “cured”. Birth control is not “preventative care”. It does not prevent a disease. It is insulting to women in my opinion to put it in the same category as maternal care and pre-cancer screenings.
As far as your trite “pre-existing condition” argument – I will say that I as an insulin dependent diabetic, I understand what a pre-existing condition is all too well. I find it insulting that that you and your accomplices feel the need to subsidize birth control under the guise of “women’s health”, and yet if I were to suggest that the government provide my insulin or diabetic supplies for free, I would be laughed off the stage. I will die if I do not take my insulin every day. No woman has ever died because they were not given free birth control.
Why is there no one in the Senate writing a bill that will provide insulin for free? I dare say that providing free or even subsidized insulin to all diabetics would be vastly cheaper than providing free birth control to %51 of the population. And there would be no argument from any religious groups because there is no ethical, moral, religious, political, or logical argument to the fact that insulin is needed to treat the very real disease that diabetes is. However, because this would only affect a relatively small proportion of your constituency, I understand that it would not have near the voter appeal, and therefore is not worth your time.
Why have you not fought hard to prevent insurance companies from charging diabetics more for health care because they are diabetics? Diabetics, many of who are breadwinners for their families, can and will continue to be asked to pay the same for their health care. Why are diabetics asked to pay more for their health care? You could make this argument for any legitimate disease – cancer, high blood pressure, mental disease – you name it, and I have yet to hear a valid argument from any of you or your comrades as to why free birth control for women has been chosen as the golden chalice to be attained at all costs other than the convenient fact that you can appeal to %51 of your voters.
I will count on your and your fellow Party members to continue to work towards keeping Michigan families to an acceptable size and work together to insure that you can get the most votes possible by spreading misinformation about flashpoint issues.
Thank you for your time.
Jesse Ekblad
United States Citizen
Registered voter
Proud Catholic